Contact Information

E-mail: brucefrancismacdonald@gmail.com

Wednesday, 19 December 2012

The 25th Battalion - Nova Scotia Rifles

During the First World War, three Nova Scotian battalions saw combat in France and Belgium as distinct fighting units - the Royal Canadian Regiment, 85th and 25th Battalions.  The Royal Canadian Regiment, based in Halifax, was the only unit in existence at the time of the war's outbreak.  Having previously served in both the Northwest Rebellion (1885) and South African (Boer) War (1899-1903), its overseas deployment was delayed by a garrison assignment in Bermuda from September 1914 until August 1915.  Upon returning to Nova Scotia, its members attested for overseas service with the Canadian Expeditionary Force (CEF), arriving in France in October 1915.  The second unit, the 85th Battalion ("Nova Scotia Highlanders") was formed entirely by volunteer enlistment in a province-wide campaign conducted throughout the autumn and winter of 1915-16. After ten months of training in England, it was deployed at the front in February 1917. 

25th Battalion Cap Badge
The third unit - 25th Battalion, "Nova Scotia Rifles" - is not as well known as its counterparts, despite the fact that it was the first Nova Scotian regiment to see action at the front.  It was officially authorized on November 7, 1914 under the command of Lt. Col. G. A. Lecain of Roundhill, Annapolis County, who immediately organized a recruitment campaign.  Regimental headquarters were established at the Halifax Armouries, with recruitment offices in Sydney, Amherst, New Glasgow, Truro and Yarmouth.  Organizational efforts were hampered by a lack of suitable training facilities.  Nevertheless, the battalion achieved full strength (1000 men) by late December 1914, with an additional ten percent "reserve" in training at the Armouries.

The 25th was not officially considered a "Highland" battalion, despite the fact that it included a kilted pipe band, nor was it was part of the "Highland Brigade" later recruited in Nova Scotia.  Military officials later prohibited its members from wearing kilts, a decision that became a sore point with many of its members.  In fact, the battalion possessed a strong "Highland" element.  It had a historical connection to the British army's Seaforth Highlanders - the "Ross Shire Buffs" - a unit originally recruited by the chiefs of Clan MacKenzie.  The 25th's official tartan was MacKenzie of Seaforth, proudly worn by its pipe band, and its members referred to themselves as the "MacKenzie Battalion" throughout the war.  Its regimental march and assembly tune was the air "Mackenzie Highlanders" , leaving no doubt as to the unit's Scottish character.

Officially organized on March 15, 1915, the 25th Battalion mustered in front of Province House in April 1915 for a ceremony at which the people of Nova Scotia presented the regiment with two fully equipped field kitchens and the sum of $ 2500 .  On May 20, 1915, its members boarded HMTS Saxonia, disembarking at Devonport, England nine days later.  The men traveled by train to Westenhanger, Kent, at which point they marched to East Sandling Camp, Shorncliffe in the early hours of the morning.

Officers' Collar Badge
The 25th Battalion was assigned to the 5th Brigade, 2nd Canadian Division, along with the 22nd (the famed "Van Doos"),  24th and 26th Battalions.  Brigade personnel was recruited entirely from Eastern Canada - specifically Quebec, Montreal, New Brunswick and Nova Scotia - and trained at Shorncliffe for three and a half months, eight hours a day, along with regular four-hour "night operations" training.  On September 15, 1915, the 5th Brigade traveled from Folkestone to Boulogne, France, moving by train the following day from Port de Brieques to St. Omer, France.  After a five-day march in their newly issued "Kitchener boots", the 25th reached the front lines in Belgium.

On the night of September 22-23, 1915, the "Mackenzie Battalion" took up combat positions near Ypres, Belgium, becoming the first Nova Scotian battalion to see combat in the war.  The regiment spent its first "tours" in trenches H and I of the Kemmel Sector of the Ypres Salient, a strategic piece of high ground that protruded into German lines.  Its members passed the autumn and winter of 1915-16 in this precarious location, gaining valuable experience "in the line".  Their military skills would be severely tested in several 1916 battles.

In April 1916, the 25th was assigned to defend the front lines in a sector referred to as the "St. Eloi craters".  The battalion moved into several large depressions created in late March 1916 when British forces detonated several large mines planted beneath the German front lines.   The 25th occupied this precarious location in a rotation that lasted for almost six weeks.  The lack of properly constructed trenches left the men dangerously exposed as they were subjected to hostile fire on three sides.  German forces attacked one crater five times during one particular night, but the battalion successfully repelled each assault.  When finally relieved, the unit's manpower had been reduced to the point where soldiers from other regiments were brought in to assist in evacuating wounded personnel.

25th Officers Capt. William A. Livingstone, MC & Bar (left) and Major Guy McLean Matheson, DSO, MC, MM
As with many other regiments, the members of the 25th sought diversions to distract them from the perils of their circumstances.  While serving in Belgium, the battalion purchased a two-week-old goat from a Belgian farmer for the grand sum of two francs.  Suitably named "Robert the Bruce" and trimmed in MacKenzie tartan, the animal served as battalion mascot for the duration of the war.  The goat was trained to prance in front of the battalion's pipe band, eat cigarettes, drink beer, and demand its blanket at "lights out".  Apparently, the animal was repeatedly sold to Belgian farmers, only to be "retrieved" by the men under cover of darkness.  At war's end, Robert the Bruce retired to a much deserved rest on the Baddeck, Nova Scotia farm of one of the battalion's most decorated officers, Major Guy McLean Matheson, MC, MM, DSO.

The "Mackenzie Battalion" spent 339 days in the treacherous Belgian trenches, 164 of which involved front line duty.  Its reassignment to the Somme region of France in September 1916 may have come as a relief to the men, but this new locale proved to be just as treacherous as the muddy trenches of Belgium.  On September 15, 1916, the 25th participated in an attack on Courcelette, moving through the town, establishing and holding new forward positions for several days before being relieved.  In the early days of October 1916, the 25th Battalion took part in a series of attacks on Regina Trench, one of the most fortified German positions on the front lines.  The price of its Somme engagements was costly.  By the time the battalion left the area, less than 100 of the men who had initially arrived in France with the unit were still available for duty.  The regiment relocated to Lens, where it was reconstituted with reinforcements and undertook training in preparation for a return to the front.

The 25th spent the autumn and winter of 1916 - 17 in the Lens sector, where its soldiers honed their skills as "trench raiders".  Its personnel captured enemy positions at Fresnoy and Arleux, France in February 1917, suffering severe casualties in the attacks.  Several months later, the unit participated in the April 9, 1917 attack on Vimy Ridge, as well as the Second Battle of the Scarpe later that same month.  On August 15, 1917, it played a key role in the Battle of Hill 70, withstanding a ferocious German counter-attack after participating in an advance near Cite St. Laurent.  As part of the 5th Brigade, the battalion also took part in the final assault on the Belgian town of Passchendaele in November 1917.

25th Battalion brass buttons
In March 1918, the 25th relocated once again to northern France, where German forces launched a major "spring offensive".  The battalion was assigned to the Mercatel-Vetasse sector during the assault.  In its aftermath, the unit established a reputation as the "Master Raiders" of the Canadian Corps, carrying out excursions into enemy outposts on each tour of front line duty.  On occasion, its soldiers ventured as far as three-quarters of a mile into German lines, earning the nickname the "raiding battalion" in recognition of their daring exploits. 

By late summer, a major Allied assault was launched on German positions in northern France.  The 25th was "in the line" at Amiens on August 8, participating in an attack that advanced a remarkable 12 miles in two days.  Relocated to Berneville, near Arras, its personnel fought in the advance that continued throughout the month.  After a brief two-day break in early September, the battalion returned to the front lines, where it remained until after the fall of Cambrai on October 9, 1918.

On November 9-10, 1918, the members of the 25th participated in what became its last combat action of the war - an attack on Elouges, a small mining town near Mons, Belgium.  The battalion was scheduled to participate in an assault on Mons the following day when news of the 11 am armistice arrived.  Eight days later, the 25th began a lengthy march to the Rhine River as part of the Allied "army of occupation".  The regiment crossed the German border at 10:08 am December 5, continuing to Bonn, where it crossed the Rhine at 10:47 am December 13, 1918.

Brass Insignia
After spending six weeks in Germany, the 25th returned to Belgium for a well-deserved rest.  On April 9, 1919, the "MacKenzie Battalion" departed Belgium for Havre, France, where it boarded the Prince Arthur, a vessel that traveled from Boston, Massachusetts to Yarmouth, Nova Scotia in the years prior to the war.  The regiment arrived at Southampton the following day and proceeded to Witley Camp, Surrey, where it encamped for one month.  Finally, on May 10, 1919, the men of the 25th began the final part of their journey home, boarding the SS Olympic at Southampton with the rest of the 5th Brigade's battalions.  The battalion was "mustered out" at Halifax on May 16, 1919 and officially disbanded on September 20, 1920. 

Altogether, 263 officers and 4829 "other ranks" served with the 25th Battalion on the battlefields of France and Belgium.  A total of 156 officers and 2557 "other ranks" were invalided as wounded or sick to England, and an additional 32 officers and 686 "other ranks" were killed in action during its tours of duty.  Of its original personnel, only 2 commissioned officers and 96 "other ranks" were still with the unit at war's end.  Unlike the other two Nova Scotian battalions that saw action in France and Belgium, the 25th Battalion was not perpetuated after the war.  Its service record at the front remains as impressive proof of the sacrifices endured by the first Nova Scotian battalion to see combat in "The Great War".

*****
Sources:

25th Battalion.  The Matrix Project.  Canadian Expeditionary Force Study Group.  Available online.

Hunt, M. S.  Nova Scotia's Part in the Great War.  Archive CD Books Canada, Inc., Manotick, Ontario (2007).  Available online.

MacNintch, John E. (Ted).  "The Brother Keepers" - Nova Scotians in the Great War.  Originally published in Celtic Heritage Magazine, Nov/Dec 2007.  Available online.

24 comments:

  1. Anyone interested in the 25th Battalion should read Robert Clements' history of it, entitled Merry Hell: The 25th (Nova Scotia Regiment) Battalion, published by University of Toronto Press in 2013. Clements was a Yarmouth man who served in the 25th throughout, rising to captain and earning the MC.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I read Merry Hell just recently. A really great read and I highly recommend it. R.N. Clements signed up on the same day as a first cousin of my grandfather named Millard Falt. Millard was also a first cousin of my wife's grandmother. My wife was adopted. Not that it matters. Clements signed as witness to Falt's attestation and Falt did the same for Clements. They ended up serving in different companies. Clements in "A" company, and Falt in "C". Falt served the full duration , with very little time off in days leave or for illness. He was wounded once but chose to remain on duty. I recall his nephew telling me that his Uncle Millard had it bad during the first war but I never paid much mind at the time because I was more interested in hearing him tell of his own experience during WW2. If I could kick myself for it, I would.

      Delete
  2. I have read Clements' book and it is an excellent source of information on the 25th. Thanks for bringing it to the attention of blog readers!

    ReplyDelete
  3. Anyone interested in the 25th Battalion may also be interested in another book, "Percy Willmot: A Cape Bretoner at War." Willmot served in the 25th and this biography is based on his letters home. Written by Brian Douglas Tennyson (Cape Breton University Press).

    ReplyDelete
  4. Sounds like a very interesting read! I'd be pleased to promote the book on my blog, Facebook page and Twitter feed, if you contact me by e-mail.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Hi Bruce, I am trying to locate the online version of the 25th War Diary. I am specifically looking for information on exactly what was done by the 25th in their preparations for the Vimy attack. Clements wrote about them being a part of the Canadian Corps preparations at Vimy (Merry Hell, pg. 165) but he is very general in his description.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Modo, you can access the 25th's war diary online at the following link:

    http://www.collectionscanada.gc.ca/archivianet/02015202_e.html

    Enter "25th Battalion" in the text box to the right of "Unit Name" and click the "Submit query" button. The 25th's war diaries are the first two results on the list that will appear on your screen. The first result contains the entries for April 1917.

    ReplyDelete
  7. Thank-you. Please keep up the great work with your interesting tweets and work with the website.

    ReplyDelete
  8. You're welcome! I will indeed continue both posts and tweets related to Guysborough County soldiers and Nova Scotian units, as we mark various anniversaries over the next several years.

    ReplyDelete
  9. My name is Stephen Poirier. My father was from Cheticamp, Cape Breton. His family claimed his uncle Napoleon Poirier served and died in WW1. But I have been unable to find records of him. We do have one of his medals, but recently I finally noticed the inscription on the edge. The name is not my father's uncle, but Private Leo Perry, 25th Infantry, 469478. He died in France on Sept. 25, 1918. I don't how my family got his medal. It is the 1914-1918 British War Medal. If anyone has any information on this please let me know. Any info can be sent to me at stevp@hotmail.com Thank you.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Stephen, I checked the name "Napoleon Poirier" in the Library & Archives Canada's CEF database and found seven soldiers by that name. Have you checked this site? You can access it at: http://www.bac-lac.gc.ca/eng/discover/military-heritage/first-world-war/personnel-records/Pages/search.aspx

      Enter the last name and first name, and click the SEARCH button for results. Contact me by e-mail if you have any further questions: brucefrancismacdonald@gmail.com . I'm happy to help in whatever way I can!

      Delete
    2. Hi,

      Thank you for your quick reply. I have looked at these records in the past. The trouble is I have very few details of Napoleon Poirier. He was the much older half brother of my grandfather, who was born in 1906. He barely knew him, and so the family had few details of his life. All we knew was he served and died in the war. I don't know where he was born, when he was born, or anything else. So one of these seven names could be him, but all is uncertain. Also, it is very odd my family has this medal with another man's name, Leo Perry. I was wondering if your research of the 25th Infantry turned up the name of Napoleon Poirier as a member. Thanks for your help.

      Stephen

      Delete
    3. Also, I have examined the CEF death records and the Commonwealth War Graves Commission and they have no record of a Napoleon Poirier dying in the war. So it is all a mystery. The lack of details frustrates the search, so maybe I will never know.

      Delete
  10. As a follow up to my previous comment on Private Leo Perry. He was from Inverness, Cape Breton. He enlisted in September 1915. He has no known grave so his name is inscribed on the Vimy Ridge Memorial. Also, if anyone has heard of a Napoleon Poirier from the Cheticamp area serving in the war I would been pleased to hear anything about him. Again send any info to stevp@hotmail.com Thank you.

    ReplyDelete
  11. looking for any information on Thomas Dwyer was in the 94th Victoria Regt for a few months

    then attested with the 25th in Halifax in the 2nd dec 1914

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. After posting the comment below, I found the citation for Thomas Dwyer's Military Medal, earned at Passchendaele, Belgium, on the night of November 6, 1917. Contact me by e-mail for a copy.

      Delete
  12. Thomas Dwyer's complete service file is available online at:

    https://www.bac-lac.gc.ca/eng/discover/military-heritage/first-world-war/personnel-records/Pages/item.aspx?IdNumber=370093

    A quick review indicates that he was awarded the Military Medal for bravery. I will check for a citation, as it may provide the details of the circumstances in which he received the award. Contact me directly by e-mail if you have any questions. My address is posted at the top of this blog.

    ReplyDelete
  13. I am trying to locate information on my grandfather, Joseph Edgar (Ed) Hatfield, from Yarmouth, who fought at Vimy Ridge. Can anyone direct me to online resources that has names of men from NS who fought at Vimy, or joined the CEF in NS? Thank you.

    ReplyDelete
  14. Hi Joan — I'd be happy to assist with your search. Please contact me by e-mail at:

    brucefrancismacdonald@gmail.com

    A quick search located a Eugene Edgar Hatfield, born at Pleasant Lake, Yarmouth County, son of Edgar J. Hatfield. However, he did not serve overseas.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hi Bruce, Wartime Heritage site out of Yarmouth shows no Edgar Hatfield or Joseph Hatfield as having served. Stanley Wellington Hatfield, son of Edgar Hatfield of Pleasant Lake, served overseas. He was a dentist and served with the Canadian Army Dental Corp. He reached the rank of Sgt. It looks like he served all of his time over there in England.

      http://wartimeheritage.com/whawwi/whawwi_those_who_served_yarmouth.htm

      Delete
    2. Thanks for the feedback. Joan and I carried on a lengthy correspondence by e-mail and discovered that her grandfather was living/working in the United States during the latter years of the First World War. after considerable digging, I came across several documents that support the conclusion that Joseph Edgar Hatfield did not enlist for military service during the First World War in either Canada or the United States.

      Delete
    3. You're welcome. I wonder if you might be able to help me. I have interest in a number of CEF units. The two that hold the greatest interest are the RCR and the 25th. I have read the war diary of the RCR. Would very much like to read that of the 25th. The link that you provided above no longer goes to where it initially did. It goes to the 1906 census of the NWT. Do you have an updated link to the diary of the 25th?

      Delete
    4. Can you contact me by e-mail? There is a way to view the diaries on the Library & Archives Canada site—too complex to explain here. There is also a printed copy of the war diary you can likely obtain through a local library. My e-mail address is at the top of the blog page.

      Delete